Alliance News

Global Aid at a Crossroads: Legal Battles Intensify Against Trump’s Foreign Aid Policies

Feb 14, 2025

Legal battles and advocacy efforts intensified to combat the chaos and devastation left in the wake of the Trump administration’s foreign aid freeze and other executive actions.

In response to the lawsuit filed on behalf of member Global Health Council and several U.S. organizations, a federal judge yesterday (February 13) issued a temporary order halting the Trump administration’s efforts to terminate foreign aid contracts and grants that were established before President Trump’s 2025 inauguration. This is a significant legal win for USAID implementing partners. 

This ruling also prevents the administration from implementing terminations, suspensions, or stop-work orders related to these existing foreign aid awards. However, the judge’s order does not prevent President Trump from enforcing a separate executive order that freezes foreign assistance for 90 days pending a review. (NYTimes, Global Health Council, Devex and KFF)

“This ruling is a vital first step toward restoring U.S. foreign assistance programs,” said Elisha Dunn-Georgiou, President of Global Health Council. “It clears the path for organizations to resume their life saving work, showcasing the best of American values: compassion, leadership, and a commitment to global health, stability, and shared prosperity.” 

Other lawsuits and advocacy efforts continue as millions globally face the loss of essential humanitarian aid and implementers of USAID’s global programs are at the brink of collapse, triggering mass layoffs and furloughs. Communications and operations at the HHS and CDC also remain restricted. And sharp cuts to U.S. biomedical research could be at stake as a result of the National Institutes of Health (“NIH,” the world’s largest biomedical research institution) cap on indirect costs. 

Here’s a brief recap based on the reporting of KFF, Devex, Global Health Technologies Coalition, Washington Post and other key sources. (see list below)

• On February 10, a Massachusetts court issued a temporary restraining order against the NIH cap on indirect costs following a lawsuit by 22 states, including California. The states contend that the cap contravenes clear Congressional directives in the federal budget. The court has set a hearing for February 21. Simultaneously, another lawsuit was filed by the Regents of the University of California and other universities, represented by the Association of American Universities, the Association of Public and Land-grant Universities, and the American Council on Education. (Science)

• Also on February 10, Public Citizen filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia on behalf of the AIDS Vaccine Advocacy Coalition (AVAC) and Journalism Development Network, Inc. (JDN), seeking emergency relief from the freeze on funding for foreign assistance. (Bloomberg Law)

• On February 7, a federal judge halted the immediate administrative leave of 2,200 USAID employees and the plan to recall nearly all overseas workers within 30 days while also reinstating 500 employees previously placed on leave. However, the court did not address the funding freeze. This decision came in response to a lawsuit filed by Democracy Forward and Public Citizen Litigation Group, representing the American Foreign Service Association and American Federation of Government Employees. (KFF)

And on the Hill,

• The Senate confirmed Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services on February 13.

• On February 11, U.S. Rep. Sara Jacobs (D-CA) introduced legislation to prevent the dissolution of USAID and ban the use of government funds to dismantle or restructure the agency. (Devex)

• Two broader issues are affecting the entire U.S. government, not just global health. First, there’s an impending March 14 deadline to prevent a government shutdown, which Congress can avert by passing either a continuing resolution or a comprehensive funding package. Second, if the executive branch disregards court orders and Congress fails to intervene, the nation could face a constitutional crisis.

Other advocacy efforts:

• Alliance members CUGH (here and here), DNDi, GAIA, Global Health Corps, Global Health Council (here, here, here, here, and here), Global Health Technologies Coalition (here, here, and here), IDEO.org, Maya Health Alliance, MedShare, Nexleaf Analytics, North Carolina Global Health Alliance (here, here, here and here), PATH, Population Services International, Seed Global Health, San Francisco Community Health Center (here and here), Stanford (here, here, and here), UC Berkeley, UCGHI, and UCSF (here, here, and here) have spoken with the press or issued statements. You can use their talking points to contact your Congressional representatives. Find your representatives here.

• Partners the CORE Group, UN Foundation, and Unlock Aid are organizing additional advocacy efforts. Former USAID Administrators Samatha Power and Andrew Natsios, as well as Council on Foreign Relations’ Prashat Yadav and many others have powerful op-eds; see more in the sources below.

• Compiling the impact are GlobalAidFreeze.com and USAIDStopWork.com with a state-by-state analysis and a call to have your organization included.

Additional resources you may find helpful:

• Unlock Aid also held an “Ask Me Anything” webinar with their legal partners; the summary is here.

• Unlock Aid is establishing an emergency bridge fund, asking those who need funding to complete this form; they will share it with prospective funders.

• Tech Change is sharing a job board and resource curation for those impacted. 

Humentum offers resources for navigating the foreign assistance pause.

Thanks to those of you who completed our brief survey last week; if you would like to add your voice, please do so here. We are compiling the results and will share them with you next week.

Sources and What We Are Reading

February 23, 2025

February 22, 2025

February 21, 2025

February 20, 2025

February 19, 2025

February 18, 2025

February 17, 2025

February 14, 2025

February 13, 2025

February 12, 2025

February 11, 2025

February 10, 2025

February 9, 2025

February 8, 2025

February 7, 2025

February 6, 2025

February 5, 2025

February 4, 2025

February 3, 2025

February 2, 2025

February 1, 2025

January 31, 2025

January 30, 2025

January 29, 2025

January 28, 2025

January 27, 2025

January 26, 2025

January 24, 2025

January 23, 2025

January 22, 205

January 21, 2025

January 20, 2025

January 17, 2025